Picture this: eyeliner It’s Friday night time, Taylor Swift is blasting, and also you’re getting equipped for an epic night time out. For your splendor appearance, you need to go with that perfectly sultry smokey eye, so what do you reach for to your make-up bag? Chances are you’re going to seize your favorite eyeliner pencil. Some of the high-quality eyeliners obtainable are pencil formulas, thanks to their novice-pleasant textures and flexibility. Not best can you operate them to line your waterline, and higher and decrease lashlines, however you may mixture them out for eyeshadow, draw photo shapes, and, of course, smudge it out into a smokey eye.
We’re so assured inside the electricity of the exceptional pencil eyeliners that we’d bet there’s no splendor seasoned out there that doesn’t have one in their kits, and it seems pro make-up artist Aya Tariq could be inclined to agree. “I think anybody must have eye pencils of their makeup bag,” she tells Marie Claire. “Eye pencils are one of those tools that can help you create a whole lot of unique looks and, relying at the formula, they will be very forgiving.”
With pencil eyeliners this kind of vital product within the make-up global, it’s no wonder that just about each splendor emblem offers one, but they aren’t all created same. Luckily, we did all of the be just right for you in locating the pleasant pencil eyeliners. Ahead, you’ll discover our favorites that encompass alternatives from Urban Decay and Hourglass Cosmetics, in addition to drugstore winners that maintain up just as properly. Whether you’re on the hunt for an regular black eyeliner or a amusing colourful alternative, this manual has got you protected.What to Look For
When it comes to locating the quality eyeliner pencil, texture is prime, says Tariq. If you’re a beginner or are looking to test with eyeliner, Tariq indicates seeking out eyeliner with a creamy texture. “Creamy textures are more forgiving and you may smudge them with a Q-tip, your finger, or a broom,” she explains. You’re additionally certain to come across gel pencils, which Tariq says have a extra opaque pigmentation, however aren’t as forgiving as other pencils and require rapid paintings if you need to combination it out. The Best Eyeliner Pencils
- Best Overall Eyeliner Pencil: Pat McGrath Labs PermaGel Ultra Glide Eye Liner Pencil (opens in new tab)
- Best Budget Eyeliner Pencil: Maybelline TattooStudio Gel Pencil (opens in new tab)
- Best Colored Eyeliner Pencil: Urban Decay 24/7 Glide-On Waterproof Eyeliner Pencil (opens in new tab)
- Best Waterproof Eyeliner Pencil: Sephora Collection 12 Hour Contour Pencil Eyeliner (opens in new tab)
- Best Clean Eyeliner Pencil: Jones Roads Beauty The Best Pencil (opens in new tab)
Maybelline TattooStudio Gel Pencil
Aya Tariq counts herself partial to this $10 pick, pronouncing it is “so, so properly.” She adds that this gel-system pencil “lasts all day,” a must in terms of eyeliner. Although you have to paintings speedy in case you need to mixture out, as soon as this liner dries, it does now not budge (hence why “tattoo” is inside the name). This gel pencil glides on like a dream with wonderful pigmented color. Speaking of color, you have your pick out of nine extremely-wealthy sun shades.
Pros: Under $15; Glides on smoothly; Dries quick; Comes in 9 shades; Waterproof; Long-wearing
Cons: Difficult to sharpen; Does no longer include sharpener
MAKEUP BY MARIO Master Pigment Pro Eyeliner Pencil
Celebrity make-up artist Mario Dedivanovic has created the appropriate eyeliner pencil for effortless smokey eyes. Thanks to this pencil’s insane smudge-capability, you can also channel Kim Kardashian in only a few swipes. This pencil features a creamy formulation that’s first rate clean to smudge and it even comes with a built-in smudge brush. Reviewers and even the professionals love the five relatively pigmented sunglasses, too. Tariq says Mario’s eyeliner pencil is “what I need an eyeliner to be.”
Pros: Comes with integrated smudge brush; Comes with sharpener; Easy to blend or smudge; Long-carrying; Highly pigmented
Cons: Over $20; Reviewers say there is little product for the rate
Urban Decay 24/7 Glide-On Waterproof Eyeliner Pencil
Urban Decay’s 24/7 Eyeliner Pencil is a cult favored for a reason. The creamy system glides throughout the lids without any tugging, and also you may not ought to worry about smudges—as soon as this liner dries, it remains put. What’s most stunning about this pencil, although, is its substantial color range. This eyeliner is available in just about each shade you could consider (33 to be exact!) in lots of finishes, so this pick out is particularly useful if you’re looking to get innovative together with your eyeliner appearance. Pro makeup artist Shadi Malek is also a large fan of this pencil, calling it her “preferred eyeliner of all time.”
Pros: Glides on smoothly; Smudge-evidence; Waterproof; Comes in 33 hues in a whole lot of finishes; Long-carrying
Cons: Does not come with sharpener; Difficult to sharpen; May transfer to undereyes
Pat McGrath Labs PermaGel Ultra Glide Eye Liner Pencil
Pat McGrath, a.okay.a. the queen of behind the scenes makeup, knew what she was doing whilst she created this eyeliner pencil. This eyeliner is a gel formula, which means it glides on particularly easy with none tugging or skipping. The buttery liner is easy to smudge before it dries and is so pigmented, you may handiest need a swipe or . While I commonly opt for liquid eyeliners, I discovered this pencil notably smooth to use and long-lasting, so I’ve been satisfied to interchange up my move-to make-up in prefer of this pencil.
Pros: Comes with sharpener; Glides on very smoothly; Long-sporting; Highly-pigmented
Cons: Over $20
This gel eyeliner pencil by means of Hourglass took home the Allure Best of Beauty Award for Best Eyeliner, so that you realize it’s true. It features a creamy, clean-to-mixture formulation, that glides seamlessly across the lid. Whether you are trying a graphic form or simply need to gently line your eyes, there’s lots of time to shape this liner into something you need earlier than it units in place. MC’s e-trade author, Julia Marzovilla, likes to apply this pencil for winged looks given that its forgiving and creates exquisite sharp lines.
Pros: Waterproof; Smudge-evidence; Long-carrying; Twist-up layout; Vegan
Cons: Over $20
Jones Roads Beauty The Best Pencil
An eyeliner it’s beginner-friendly and made with absolutely smooth components? We love to look it! This select from Jones Roads Beauty is particularly superb for makeup novices way to its blendability—for a no-frills smokey eye, you just ought to sweep this liner throughout the lid and smudge out. Besides black, this pencil is offered in 5 other rather-pigmented shades that can also be mixed out into eyeshadow. Clean components and flexibility mean this eyeliner pencil is a win-win.
Pros: Clean system; Glides on easily; Can draw sharp traces or be smudged out
Cons: Over $20; Reapplication can be wanted; Does no longer come with sharpener
Kulfi Underlined Kajal Clean Waterproof Long-Wear Eyeliner
Another Allure Best of Beauty 2022 Award (mainly for its deeper colorations), Tariq says she’s “obsessed” with this water resistant eyeliner from Kulfi. “They’re gel, retractable and they stay well! They sincerely figured something out with their system and the colors are beautiful,” she explains. Its pretty hues consist of a shimmery berry, leafy green, and sky blue, just to call some. This underrated pick out certainly lives up to its call, too—it lasts all day and won’t budge below your eyes.
Pros: Vegan; Waterproof; Long-wearing; Comes in seven shades in two finishes; Twist-up design
Cons: May smudge after some time
Rimmel London Automatic Exaggerate Eye Definer
At simply $five, this drugstore preferred is the best in shape for everyone looking to test with their eyeliner. Whether you are going for a photograph form or a smoked-out look, this liner sets speedy for a long-lasting end. Its twist-up layout method you do not must worry about carrying a sharpener, plus it comes with a integrated smudge sponge. Tons of reviewers say this is their “pass-to” liner thanks to its price range-friendly rate and method that stays placed.
Pros: Under $15; Twist-up layout; Highly pigmented